Historiography on the “Siberian” Period of Mikhail Bakunin (1857-1861): A Critical Discourse
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7596/taksad.v8i4.2387Keywords:
Mikhail Bakunin, Siberian periods, myths, Soviet historiography, agitation.Abstract
The paper critically reviews the available scientific and biographical literature, which examines the four-year period of social activity of the Russian thinker and opposition politician Mikhail Bakunin in Siberia during the “thaw” of the late 1850s and early 1860s. The purpose of the study is to provide critical perspectives on the myths of historiography that interfere with the reconstruction of Mr. Bakunin’s “Siberian period.” Thus, the author of the article aims to achieve the restoration of Mikhail Bakunin’s place and role in the public life of Russia in those times. In particular, the author refutes the myth that the “great rebel” was allegedly in a voluntary self-isolation during that period of his life. In addition, the dubious source of this historiographical version is critically analyzed, dating back to Mikhail Katkov, a very famous ideologist of imperial conservatism. The author argues that the Katkov’s legend turned into a toolbox of official communist historiography, and then it was reproduced virtually unchanged in publications of the Soviet era until the collapse of the dominant regime. First of all, the author proposes to radically rethink the false conception of the "Siberian" period of Mikhail Bakunin that has become entrenched in historical literature. Second, the author considers it necessary to justify the redirection of the copyright affiliation of some sources of radical revolutionary journalism in 1860-1861 to Mikhail Bakunin, including the famous "Letters" (1860) to the editorial office of the Russian emigrant newspaper "The Bell." Based on the methodology of textual content analysis of the keywords inherent in this journalistic message and similar letters from Mr. Bakunin from Siberia, the author formulates the main conclusion: the real author of this appeal at that moment could be only the closest friend and associate of Alexander Herzen, i.e., Mr. Bakunin himself.
References
Alekseev, N. A. (1968). Was Chernyshevsky the author of the proclamation “Barsky peasants”? In N.G. Chernyshevsky. Articles, studies and materials (vol. 5) (pp. 187-204). Saratov, USSR.
Azanov, V. I. (1971). To the question of the author of the proclamation “Barsky peasants.” In N.G. Chernyshevsky. Articles, studies and materials (vol. 6) (pp. 173-198). Saratov, USSR.
Baglay, M. V. (1994). The road to freedom. Moscow, Russia.
Bakunin, M. A. (1862, February 15). Russian, Polish and all Slavic friends. The Bell, 5(122-123), 1021-1028.
Bakunin, M. A. (1935). Collected works and letters (vol. 4). Moscow, Russia.
Belogolovyy, N. A. (1987). Memories and other articles. Moscow, Russia.
Block, A. A. (1971). Mikhail Alexandrovich Bakunin. In Collected Works in 6 volumes (vol. 5) (pp. 27-30). Moscow, USSR.
Demin, V. N. (2008). Siberian Prometheus. In V. N. Demin (Ed.), Bakunin (pp. 167-232). Moscow, Russia.
Dolzhikov, V. A. (1989). M.A. Bakunin and Siberia in the era of the first revolutionary situation (1857–1861) (Cand. of Sci. Diss.). Tomsk, USSR.
Dolzhikov, V. A. (1992). “Siberian” factor in the evolution of political views M.A. Bakunin. In Questions of Political History and Political Science: Collection of scientific articles (pp. 3-18). Barnaul, Russia.
Dolzhikov, V. A. (1993). M.A. Bakunin and Siberia (1857–1861). Novosibirsk, Russia.
Dolzhikov, V. A. (2000). M. A. Bakunin in the national-regional political process of the “thaw” era (1850-1860s). Barnaul, Russia.
Dolzhikov, V. A. (2018). M.A. Bakunin in the national-regional political process of the “thaw” era (1850–1860s) (2nd ed., revised). Barnaul, Russia.
Dyakov, V. A., & Rudnitskaya, E. L. (1974). Manuscript by M.A. Bakunin entitled “The International Secret Society for the Liberation of Humanity” (1864). In The revolutionary situation in Russia in 1859–1861. Moscow, USSR.
Goryushkin, L. M. (1986). The place of Siberia as part of Russia during the period of capitalism. In Historical experience in the development of Siberia: Interuniversity collection of scientific papers (pp. 37-50). Novosibirsk, USSR.
Grafsky, V. G. (1985). Bakunin. From the history of political ideas. Moscow, USSR.
Kaminski, A. (2012). Michail Bakunin: zycie i mysl (vol. 1). Wroclaw, Poland.
Katkov, M. N. (1870, January 6). Moscow, January 5. Moscow Gazette, 4.
Kitaev, V. A. (1967). Herzen and Bakunin on the eve of the uprising of 1863 in Poland. Scientific notes of Gorky University: Series in History, 85, 43-48.
Koshovenko, A. E. (1960). On the London meeting of N.G. Chernyshevsky with A.I. Herzen in 1859 and the formula “Cavelin squared.” In The revolutionary situation in Russia in 1859–1861 (pp. 271-282). Moscow, USSR.
Kozmin, B. P. (1929). Kazan conspiracy of 1863. Moscow, USSR.
Kubalov, B. G. (1923). Pages of life M.A. Bakunin and his family in Siberia. Proceedings of Professors and Teachers of the State Irkutsk University, 5, 128-135.
Lantsov, S. A. (2009). Political history of Russia: Textbook. St. Petersburg, Russia.
Lemke, M. (1923). Peasant unrest of 1855. Red Chronicle, 7, 131-177.
Mikhailov, M. I. (1988). Petty-bourgeois rebellion in the era of industrial capitalism. Moscow, USSR.
Novikova, N.N., & Kloss, B.M. (1981). N.G. Chernyshevsky led by the revolutionaries of 1861: some results and prospects of the study. Moscow, USSR.
Pantin, I. K., & Plimak, E. G. (1979). “The Age of 1861” in Russia (Toward a Research Methodology). Questions of Philosophy, 10, 97-109.
Pirumova, N. M. (1986). Bakunin in Siberia. Questions of History, 9, 103-114.
Pirumova, N. M. (1990). Social doctrine of M.A. Bakunin. Moscow, Russia.
Podshivalov, I. Yu. (2015). Sibiriada of Mikhail Bakunin. In I. Yu. Podshivalov (Ed.), Anarchy in Siberia (pp. 81-90). Moscow, Russia: Сommon place.
Political history: Russia – USSR – Russian Federation (vol. 1). (1996). Moscow, Russia: State Print.
Polonsky, V. (1926). Bakunin – Jacobin. Bulletin of the Communist Academy, 18, 42-62.
Polonsky, V. (1933). Preface to the letters of M. A. Bakunin to M.N. Katkov from Siberia. In Materials for the biography of M. Bakunin (vol. 2) (pp. 497-499). Moscow & Leningrad, USSR.
Polonsky, V. P. (1921). Mikhail Bakunin in the era of the forties and sixties. In Bakunin M.A. Confession (vol. 3) (pp. 3-41). Moscow, Russia.
Pugachev, V. V. (1966). Monograph on “Earth and Freedom.” Scientific notes of Gorky University: Series in History and Philology, 78, 513-517.
Pushkin, B. (1923). M.A. Bakunin according to the reports of the III Branch. Red Archive, 3, 199-200.
Sesyunina, M. G. (1974). G. N. Potanin and N.M. Yadrintsev as the ideologists of Siberian regionalism. Tomsk, USSR.
Shilovsky, M. V. (1989). Siberian oblasts in the socio-political movement in the late 50-60s of the XIX century. Novosibirsk, USSR.
Sukhotina, L. G. (1992). To the history of revolutionary-democratic exile in Tomsk. In Problems of the socio-political life of Siberia in the 19th century (pp. 66-74). Barnaul, Russia.
The State Archive of the Russian Federation (GARF). F. 95. Op. 1. D. 302. Part IV. (n.d.)
Volodin, A. I., Karjakin, Yu. F., & Plimak, E. G. (1976). Chernyshevsky or Nechaev? Moscow, Russia.
Vyrubov, G. N. (1913) Revolutionary memories (Herzen, Bakunin, Lavrov). Bulletin of Europe, 2, 45-70.
Downloads
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
All papers licensed under Creative Commons 4.0 CC-BY.- Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
- Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially.
Under the following terms:
Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
- No additional restrictions — You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.
