Stolypin's Resettlement Policy and the Problem of the Land Issue Softening in European Russia: Assessments of the German-Speaking Russian Studies of the 20th Century

Andrey G. Dorozhkin, Vladimir Filatov, Aleksey Tomarov, Alexandr Kozyr, Svetlana Velikanova, Oksana Chernykh

Özet


In Germanic studies of Russia, the issue of the resettlement movement to Asian Russia prospects was regarded at the beginning of the twentieth century, which became much more active during the years of the Stolypin reform, to defuse the acuteness of the agrarian issue in the European part of the empire. In this regard, the attention was drawn to the extent of migration to Siberia and to the categories of migrants. After a long break, the interest to the problem resumed in the German-speaking historiography during the 60-70s of the 20th century. The researchers of Germany, and somewhat later of Austria, paid a close attention to the factor of "back migration", the return of migrants to their former place of residence due to unfavorable circumstances, to these very unfavorable circumstances, largely in solidarity with Soviet historians during the explanation of the reasons for re-immigration. And not without the influence of the latter, the possibilities of resettlement to contribute to the mitigation of the agrarian problem in European Russia were usually considered skeptically. However, since the mid-1980s, there has been a clear overcoming of pessimistic assessments and conclusions. The Austrian historian A. Moritsch and the West German researcher D. Landgraf drew attention to the place of origin of the peasants who moved to Siberia and the Far East, analyzed the causes of "back migration" more closely, stressed that, with all the difficulties of adaptation to life in a new place, the majority of migrants still did not repatriate, which had a positive effect both for the progress of agriculture in Asian Russia, and (with all possible reservations) for the situation with the agrarian issue in the European part of the country.


Anahtar Kelimeler


Russia, Siberia, Far East, Resettlements, Agrarian issue, German-speaking historiography, Stolypin.

Tam Metin:

PDF (English)

Referanslar


Deeg, L. (1996). Die Geschichte eines deutschen Handelshauses im russischen Fernen Osten. 1864-1924. Essen: Klartext-Verl. [in German].

Dietze, C. (1920). Stolypinsche Agrarreform und Feldgemeinschaft. Berlin. [in German].

Dorozhkin, A. G. (2004). Industrial and agrarian development of pre-revolutionary Russia: the view of German-speaking historians of the twentieth century. Moscow: Magnitogorsk. [in Russian].

Dorozhkin, A. G.; Makarova, N. N.; Bezrukov, A. V.; Popov, M. V.; Velikanova, S. S. & Chernykh O. P. (2018). The Resettlement movement to the Far East during Stolypin’s reform in the assessment of German-speaking Russian experts of the second half of the 20th Century. The Turkish Online Journal of Design, Art and Communication - TOJDAC ISSN: 2146-5193, March 2018. Special Edition, p. 404-409 [in English].

Efimov, O. V. (1995). Anglo-American historiography of reforms by P. A. Stolypin. Formation and evolution of concepts. Author's abstract from the diss by the cand. of hist. sciences. St. Petersburg. [in Russian].

Felch, P. (1984). Die Binnenmigration in Russland am Ende des 19. Jahrhunderts. XV. Oesterreichische Historikertag. Salzburg, pp. 248-250. [in German].

Handbuch der Geschichte Russlands (1982). Bd. 3. Lfg. 5 /6. Stuttgart, 1982. [in German].

Hoetzsch, O. (1917). Russland. Eine Einfuehrung auf Grund seiner Geschichte vom japanischen bis zum Weltkrieg. Berlin: Reimer. [in German].

Landgraf, D. (1989). Amur, Ussuri, Sachalin. 1847–1917. Muenchen: Hieronymus. [in German].

Moritsch, A. (1986). Landwirtschaft und Agrarpolitik in Russland vor der Revolution. Wien-Koeln-Graz: Boehlaus Nachf. [in German].

Nötzold, J. (1966). Wirtschaftspolitische Alternativen der Entwicklung Russlands in der Aera Witte und Stolypin. Berlin. [in German].

Preyer, W. D. (1914). Die russische Agrarreform. Jena. [in German].

Raupach, H. (1968). Geschichte der Sowjetwirtschaft. Reinbek bei Hamburg. [in German].

Russian history (1993). No. 6. pp. 191-193. [in Russian].

Selunskaya, N. B. (1995). Russia at the turn of the ХIХ - ХХ centuries (in the writings of Western historians). Moscow: Russian Open University. [in Russian].

Shashina, E. B. (1992). Pages of the Agrarian History of Russia in the Reading of Western Historians. Domestic History, 4, 191-194. [in Russian].

Spiess, K. (1980). Periphere Sowjetwirtschaft. Das Beispiel Russisch-Fernost 1897-1970. Zurich: Atlantis. [in German].

Stökl, G. (1973). Russische Geschichte von den Anfaengen bis zur Gegenwart. Stuttgart. [in German].

Tyukavkin, V. G. (2001). Great-Russian peasantry and Stolypin's agrarian reform. Moscow: Monuments of Historical Thought. [in Russian].

Zyryanov, P. N. (1973). Modern Anglo-American Historiography of the Stolypin Agrarian Reform. History of the USSR, 6, 186-195. [in Russian].




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7596/taksad.v7i4.1853

Refback'ler

  • Şu halde refbacks yoktur.




Telif Hakkı (c) 2018 Journal of History Culture and Art Research

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.