Peculiarities of the Nature and Status of the Russian Presidential Administration: Historical, Political and Legal Overview

Anton Vladimirovich Zuykov

Özet


The Presidential Administration in the Russian Federation has never been just an adminicular mechanism of the head of state. Unlike its western analogs, it has always possessed an incomparably large resource of power. While presidents were changed, the personal stuff, structure and authorities of this body were also changed, but its central place in the management system of the Russian state remained stable. The Administration of the President of the Russian Federation is an institution, whose legal status does not have a clear legal shape. Not without reason the journalists, as well as lawyers, political scientists and historians sometimes call it the shadow government or the secret order. However, the legal nature of the administration of the President of the Russian Federation is not quite clear. Even the name "Administration" is often misleading: whether the Administration of the President of the Russian Federation may be considered the executive power or the public administration in a wider sense? This and other disputes about the nature of the Presidential Administration of the Russian Federation and its legal status have arisen in the expert community with the beginning of complex work on the constitutional project, and are still ongoing today. In this regard, the author of this article decided to make one of the first attempts in the country to investigate what the Administration of the President of the Russian Federation really is, what are the problems associated with its functioning, and whether there are legal means to resolve them at the present stage. To answer these questions, the author thoroughly analyzes the models and arguments proposed at different stages of the development of the new Russia, and correlates them with the basic constitutional principles.


Anahtar Kelimeler


Constitutional principles, Rule of law, Russian Presidential Administration, President, Chief of Staff, Constitutional commission, Constitutional assembly, Auxiliary offices, Head of state, Apparatus, Legal draft.

Tam Metin:

PDF (English)

Referanslar


Andrias, Kate (2013). The President’s enforcement power. New York University Law Review. Vol. 88. № 4. Oct. 2013. P. 1031-1125.

Arutyunyan, Gagik & Baglay, Marat (2006). An Encyclopaedia of Constitutional Law. Moscow, 2006. P. 13-14.

Avakyan, Suren (2010). Сonstitutionalist reflections: Selected articles. Moscow, 2010. P. 237-246.

Avakyan, Suren (2015). The Constitutional Lexicon: A Terminological Dictionary of State Law. Moscow, 2015. P. 54-59.

Blumstein, James F. (2001). Regulatory review by the Executive office of the President: an overview and policy analysis of current issues. Duke Law Journal. Vol. 51. № 3. Dec. 2001. P. 851-899.

Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation (1996). № 41. Art. 4689.

Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation (1997). № 51. Art. 5712.

Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation (2004). № 15. Art. 1395.

Filatov, Sergey; Chernomyrdin, Viktor & Shakhray, Sergey; Yarov, Yury; Sobchak, Anatoly & Shumeyko, Vladmir (1995). The Constitutional Assembly: Transcripts, Materials, Documents. April 29 - November 10, 1993. Volume 1. April 29 - June 4. Moscow, 1995. P. 11-66.

Filatov, Sergey; Chernomyrdin, Viktor & Shakhray, Sergey; Yarov, Yury; Sobchak, Anatoly & Shumeyko, Vladmir (1995).Transcript of a Meeting of the representatives of the federal executive bodies for amending the project of the Constitution of Russia. The Constitutional Assembly: Transcripts, Materials, Documents. April 29 - November 10, 1993. Volume 6. June 11, 1993. Moscow, 1995. P. 95,96,101.

Filatov, Sergey; Chernomyrdin, Viktor & Shakhray, Sergey; Yarov, Yury; Sobchak, Anatoly & Shumeyko, Vladmir (1996). Transcript of a Meeting of a Working Commission for amending the Project of the Constitution of Russia (June 21, 1993). The Constitutional Assembly: Transcripts, Materials, Documents. April 29 - November 10, 1993. Vol. 12. June 18, 19, 21, 1993. Moscow, 1996. P. 328.

Filatov, Sergey; Chernomyrdin, Viktor & Shakhray, Sergey; Yarov, Yury; Sobchak, Anatoly & Shumeyko, Vladmir (1996). Transcript of a Meeting of a Working Commission for amending the Project of the Constitution of Russia (October 18, 1993). The Constitutional Assembly: Transcripts, Materials, Documents. April 29 - November 10, 1993. Vol. 18. September 8 - October 21, 1993. Moscow, 1996. P. 120-122.

General Explanatory Dictionary of Russian (2018). URL: http://tolkslovar.ru/a1473.html (accessed on 23.02.2018).

Ivanov, Maxim (2013). The Presidential Administration is advised to obey a law. Kommersant, 2013, November 6.

Kagan, Elena (2001). Presidential Administration. Harvard Law Review. Vol. 114. № 8. June. 2001. P. 2245-2385.

Law of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic (1991). № 1098-1 ‘’On the President of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic’’, Proceedings of the Congress of the People’s Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the RSFSR. 1991. № 17. Art. 512.

Law of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic (1991). № 1326-1 ‘’On amendments and additions to the Constitution / the Basic Law of the Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic’’, Proceedings of the Congress of the People’s Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the RSFSR. 1991. № 22. Art. 776.

Lessig, Lawrence & Sunstein, Cass R. (1994). The President and the Administration. Columbia Law Review. Vol. 94. № 1. Jan. 1994. Р. 1-123;

Merrill, Thomas W. (2015). Presidential Administration and the traditions of administrative law. Columbia Law Review. Vol. 115. № 7. Nov. 2015. Р. 1953-1984.

Metzger, Gillian E. (2013). Administrative Constitutionalism. Texas Law Review. Vol. 91. № 7. June. 2013. P. 1897-1936.

Metzger, Gillian E. (2015). Administrative law, public administration, and the administrative conference oh the United States. The George Washington Law Review. Vol. 83. № 4/5. Sept. 2015. P. 1517-1539.

Official website of Oleg Rumyantsev (2018). URL: http://rumiantsev.ru/a617/ (accessed on 23.02.2018).

Rumyantsev, Oleg (1991). From the history of drafting the Russian Constitution. The Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials and documents (1990 - 1993). In six volumes. Volume 2 (1991). Moscow, 2009. P. 251-259.

Rumyantsev, Oleg (1992). Draft of the Russian Constitution. URL: http://rumiantsev.ru/a630/ (accessed on 23.02.2018).

Rumyantsev, Oleg (2009). Draft of the Russian Constitution, July 12, 1993. From the history of drafting the Russian Constitution. The Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials and documents (1990 - 1993). In six volumes. Vol. 4. Book 3. (July - December 1993). Moscow, 2009. P. 191-236.

Rumyantsev, Oleg (2009). Draft of the Russian Constitution, March 2, 1993. From the history of drafting the Russian Constitution. The Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials and documents (1990 - 1993). In six volumes. Vol. 4. Book 1. (January - April 1993). Moscow, 2009. P. 80-120.

Rumyantsev, Oleg (2009). From the history of drafting the Russian Constitution. The Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials and documents (1990 - 1993). In six volumes. Vol. 2. (1991). Moscow, 2009. P. 277-323; 564-608.

Rumyantsev, Oleg (2009). From the history of drafting the Russian Constitution. The Constitutional Commission: transcripts, materials and documents (1990 - 1993). In six volumes. Vol. 3. Book 1. (January - June 1992). Moscow, 2009. P. 80-120.

Shakhray, Sergey (2013). Unknown Constitution. Constitutio incognita. Moscow.

The Decision of the Government of the Russian Federation (2004) № 260 ‘’On the Rules of the Government of Russia and the Regulation on the Apparatus of the Government’’, Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation. № 23. Art. 2313.

The Decision of the State Duma (1996). № 781-II GD ‘’on referring the Constitutional Court of Russia”, November 11, 1996’’, Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation. 1996. № 49. Art. 5506.

The Presidential Decree (April 15 1997). № 352 ‘’On changes and additions to the Regulation on the Presidential Administration of Russia, approved by the Presidential Decree on October 2, 1996, № 1412’’, Collection of legislative acts of the Russian Federation. 1997. № 16. Art. 1857.

The Presidential Decree of the RSFSR (1991). № 13 ‘’On the Presidential Administration of the RSFSR’’, Official Internet Gateway of Legal Information. URL: http://pravo.gov.ru/proxy/ips/?docbody=&firstDoc=1&lastDoc=1&nd=102012108 (accessed on 23.02.2018)

Weis, Lael K. (2014). Constitutional amendment rules and interpretive fidelity to democracy. Melbourne University Law Review. Vol. 38. № 1. May. 2014. P. 240-280.

Wurman, Ilan (2017). Constitutional Administration. Stanford Law Review. Volume 69. № 2. Feb. 2017. P. 359-434.

Zuykov, Anton (2009). The Evolution of the institution of the Presidency of the Russian Federation, Ph. D. in Law thesis. Moscow.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7596/taksad.v7i1.1461

Refback'ler

  • Şu halde refbacks yoktur.




Telif Hakkı (c) 2018 Journal of History Culture and Art Research

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.